Winamp Logo
True Myths, One Lie with Culter35 Cover
True Myths, One Lie with Culter35 Profile

True Myths, One Lie with Culter35

English, Human interest, 1 season, 54 episodes, 1 day, 7 hours, 31 minutes
About
Does Bigfoot eat pizza on Sundays? What about those secret underground bunkers only the illuminati have access to? Culter35 (aka Anthony Mennella) here to be your host on the weirdest, wildest, off the wall game show of all time. Culter35 will test his guests by telling them 3 stories. They will be tasked with deciphering the clues, putting on their tin foil hats, and trying to sort reality from fiction. Will they be able to decipher which stories are claimed to be true, and can they figure out which one is a figment of Culter35’s insane imagination?
Episode Artwork

The Backrooms, Inescapable Alternate Realities ft. Christopher Mennella, Ryan McCauley, Seth Colon, and Ryan Feeney

Have you ever been somewhere that just feels "off"? You might've accidentally stumbled into a backroom, a creepy room in a different reality than our own that you can unknowingly glitch into, and which can house a terrifying creature. This week, Anthony and gang hear three stories involving people "no clipping" into mysterious, otherworldly rooms that seemed like there was no exit. Plus, the guys play a choose your own adventure game where they try to escape their own backroom. And with the first virtual episode, there's plenty of Zoom shenanigans. Download Best Fiends FREE today on the App Store or Google Play! Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Watch the podcast on YouTube: https://bit.ly/TrueMythsOneLieYT Don’t forget to subscribe to the podcast for free wherever you're listening or by using this link: http://bit.ly/TrueMythsOneLiePodcast Follow Culter35 on IG   Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
1/25/202237 minutes, 43 seconds
Episode Artwork

A House in the Woods ft. Christopher Mennella and Austin Murphy

Picture a house, not creepy on its own, right? Well, put that same house in the woods and the creepy factor goes way up. This week, Culter35 and crew listen to 3 stories involving mysterious homes surrounded by trees and involve some type of paranormal activity. Scary phone calls, and creatures stalking people, so much more. One of the stories Anthony made up, can you discern fact from fiction? Plus, the guys play "Would You Rather?," with both choices involve being scared the whole time. Get 10% off your first month by visiting our sponsor at BetterHelp.com/culter35 Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Watch the podcast on YouTube: https://bit.ly/TrueMythsOneLieYT Don’t forget to subscribe to the podcast for free wherever you're listening or by using this link: http://bit.ly/TrueMythsOneLiePodcast Follow Culter35 on IG   Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
1/18/202235 minutes, 16 seconds
Episode Artwork

Meeting Your Future Self: Time Traveler Stories ft. Christopher Mennella

Have you ever wondered what you'll be like in the future? According to these stories, it's entirely possible. This week, the Mennella brothers read through 3 stories regarding people time traveling or crossing timelines and interacting with their younger selves. Can you figure out which of the three is made up (without skipping ahead) or are you in a timeline where you guess wrong? Plus, Anthony and Christopher make up a brand-new science fiction story using 3 random words: Toad from Mario, Igloo, and Portal. To get your new wireless plan for just $15 a month, and get the plan shipped to your door for FREE, go to MINTMOBILE.com/culter Get 10% off your first month by visiting our sponsor at BetterHelp.com/culter35  Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Watch the podcast on YouTube: https://bit.ly/TrueMythsOneLieYT Don’t forget to subscribe to the podcast for free wherever you're listening or by using this link: http://bit.ly/TrueMythsOneLiePodcast Follow Culter35 on IG   Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
1/11/202234 minutes, 59 seconds
Episode Artwork

New Stories From 2021's Most Popular Topics ft. Ryan McCauley, Austin Murphy, and Christopher Mennella

It's the start of the new year, but it's time to look back at some of the most popular episodes from 2021! You loved stories about Aliens, Black-eyed Children, and Dogmen, so Anthony is bringing you 3 new stories, one each of the top 3 from last years. But even though we've got 12 new months of ahead of us, some things never change. One of the 3 stories was totally made up, so hopefully one of your New Year's Resolutions involved getting better at figuring out which story is a lie. Plus, the guys are ambushed with a mini game where they have to invent a brand-new mythical creature, hopefully one that will be the subject of a future episode! Download Best Fiends FREE today on the App Store or Google Play! Get 10% off your first month by visiting BetterHelp.com/culter35 Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Watch the podcast on YouTube: https://bit.ly/TrueMythsOneLieYT Don’t forget to subscribe to the podcast for free wherever you're listening or by using this link: http://bit.ly/TrueMythsOneLiePodcast Follow Culter35 on IG   Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
1/4/202232 minutes, 56 seconds
Episode Artwork

Bob's Wild Childhood Stories ft. Ryan McCauley, Andrew Heinlein, and Christopher Mennella

In a twist on the format, this week, Anthony gets in on the action. Bob McLaughlin, who is the father to popular YouTubers Jillian and Addie, sent in 3 absolutely insane childhood stories, one of which is not true. No one on the episode, including Culter35, know which story is the lie. The stories include paranormal encounters and running into super shady characters. Can you guess which one Bob made up? Plus, in another Bob-inspired mini-games called "Bob's Jobs," where Bob also submitted various unusual jobs that he may or may not have done. Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Watch the podcast on YouTube: https://bit.ly/TrueMythsOneLieYT Don’t forget to subscribe to the podcast for free wherever you're listening or by using this link: http://bit.ly/TrueMythsOneLiePodcast Follow Culter35 on IG Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
12/28/202141 minutes, 42 seconds
Episode Artwork

Elf Sightings ft. Ryan McCauley, Austin Murphy, and Christopher Mennella

Elves are usually associated with Santa and Christmas, but I don't think these stories will fill you with the same holiday glee. This week, the guys discuss 3 elf sighting stories that are less festive and more terrifying. These evil elves aren't bringing Christmas gifts as much as horror and pain. One of the 3 stories is a lie, can you guess which one? Plus, despite everyone's complaints, Anthony and crew play a round of "Guess Who" where the guests try to guess the correct mythical creature with just a few questions. Don’t fall for subscription scams. Start cancelling today at Truebill.com/CULTER Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Watch the podcast on YouTube: https://bit.ly/TrueMythsOneLieYT Don’t forget to subscribe to the podcast for free wherever you're listening or by using this link: http://bit.ly/TrueMythsOneLiePodcast Follow Culter35 on IG   Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
12/21/202133 minutes, 50 seconds
Episode Artwork

Krampus AKA Evil Santa ft. Ryan McCauley, Seth Colon, and Christopher Mennella

We all love jolly ole Santa Claus, the chubby red-suited hero who brings us presents ever year on Christmas. Well, the guy we're talking about today ain't him. Krampus is an Eastern European legend that will haunt your holiday nightmares. This week, Culter and crew discuss 3 stories of run-ins with the giant horned demon-like creature, just in time for the holiday season. So which one of the three is NOT Krampus canon? Tune in to find out! Take advantage of SimpliSafe’s Holiday deals and get 40% off your new home security system by visiting SIMPLISAFE.com/culter  Get 10% off your first month by visiting BetterHelp.com/culter35 Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Watch the podcast on YouTube: https://bit.ly/TrueMythsOneLieYT Don’t forget to subscribe to the podcast for free wherever you're listening or by using this link: http://bit.ly/TrueMythsOneLiePodcast Follow Culter35 on IG   Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
12/14/202134 minutes, 11 seconds
Episode Artwork

La Llorona ft. Ryan McCauley, Andrew Heinlein, and Christopher Mennella

Also known as "The Weeping Woman" or "The Wailer", La Llorona is a Latin American folklore legend who allegedly drowned her children who can be summoned in the mirror. There are many stories of encounters with her, and you're about to hear 3 of them, plus a bonus story of a personal encounter. told by one of the guests. Story 1: A girl plays by a river near sunset when she hears a woman crying. She approaches the crying woman wearing all white, so she runs away. She feels a cold hand on her shoulder, but safely makes it home, though the cold hand feeling lingers a little too long. Story 2: A couple travels to Mexico to visit the man's parents. At night, the man gets cold so he goes to close the window when he hears loud wailing. It grows and louder, including barking and banging from the stray dog outside. Just as it gets as loud as possible, the noise completely stops. The next day, the dog is nowhere in sight, leaving only some stray hairs. Story 3: A few girls are playing when one of the girls suddenly feels anxious, shortly followed by crying and wailing. The girls look out the window when the noise gets extremely loud. The grandmother bursts in with holy water and prayers, causing more paranormal activity. Plus, the guests get bombarded with a game of "Guess Who" with a mythical creature. Download Best Fiends FREE today on the App Store or Google Play! Don’t fall for subscription scams. Start cancelling today at Truebill.com/CULTER Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Watch the podcast on YouTube: https://bit.ly/TrueMythsOneLieYT Don’t forget to subscribe to the podcast for free wherever you're listening or by using this link: http://bit.ly/TrueMythsOneLiePodcast Follow Culter35 on IG   Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
12/7/202137 minutes, 43 seconds
Episode Artwork

Crybaby Bridge ft. Andrew Heinlein, Ryan McCauley, and Christopher Mennella

This week, Anthony and gang discuss 3 stories involving a crybaby bridge, which is some type of legend surrounding a bridge where a baby or child has died, often at the hands of their own mother, and has now cursed the bridge to be forever haunted. So which of the following 3 stories is less than true? Listen to find out! Story 1: A murderous cult threw a baby off of a bridge around the time that it was being constructed. One woman contends that while she and her friend were crossing the bridge, their car cuts out and comes to a complete stop. They hear a woman cackling, getting louder and louder. They finally get the car to start and speed off, spotting a mysterious woman staring at them. Story 2: A woman has a child out of wedlock, causing her father to kill the baby's father. He also throws the baby off of the bridge. A few friends go to the now-closed bridge and spot a deformed baby crawling around. Story 3: Around the time of the Civil War, runaway women were cornered on the bridge. Instead of dooming their children to a life of slavery, they instead throw them over the bridge. Many decades later, a group of friends go over to the bridge at night to investigate, but don't find anything for a while. Just as they are leaving, they hear a baby crying and a splash in the water. Plus, the guys play a new game called "Never Have I Ever, Spooky Edition" where the guys reveal times they've been scared in various situations. Don’t fall for subscription scams. Start cancelling today at Truebill.com/CULTER Get 10% off your first month by visiting our sponsor at BetterHelp.com/culter35 Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Watch the podcast on YouTube: https://bit.ly/TrueMythsOneLieYT Don’t forget to subscribe to the podcast for free wherever you're listening or by using this link: http://bit.ly/TrueMythsOneLiePodcast. Follow Culter35 on IG   Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
11/30/202136 minutes, 40 seconds
Episode Artwork

Fan-Submitted Stories! ft. Seth Colon, Austin Murphy, Christopher Mennella and YOU!

On a very special episode, Culter reads three creepy stories that were submitted by YOU, including one that supplies the lie of the episode. Listen to the supernatural experiences of other TMOL fans and find out which one among you is a liar! Story 1 from Abbie Meyer: A group of friends are playing on a playground when they decide to venture to the creepy rusty door leading into the school that has always intrigued them. When they enter, they see a doll on the floor being approached by a mysterious shadowy figure, causing the girls to all run out in freight. Shortly after, the school was suspiciously shut down forever. Story 2 from Lightweight Games: A family moves into a new house that causes . One day, the boy's iPad dies, so he goes upstairs to get the charger. When they get there, everything goes black until a large figure comes into focus, making him think there's an intruder in the home. When the rest of the family investigates, they don't find anyone. Story 3 from Will Heiner: 2 brothers go to the movies when they find they're the only ones in the theatre. They both get a creepy feeling like someone is watching them, but there's no one else around. He finally he hears a whisper in his ear, prompting the brothers to leave as fast as possible. Before they leave, one brother goes to the bathroom and hears scratching and the same whisper. When he leaves, his brother says no one else entered the bathroom the entire time. Plus, the guys play a game of Mad Lib with a yet another fan submission, where the guests replace some key details with their own. Mad Lib story submitted by Harold777. Don’t fall for subscription scams. Start cancelling today at Truebill.com/CULTER Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Watch the podcast on YouTube: https://bit.ly/TrueMythsOneLieYT Don’t forget to subscribe to the podcast for free wherever you're listening or by using this link: http://bit.ly/TrueMythsOneLiePodcast Follow Culter35 on IG Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
11/23/202140 minutes, 16 seconds
Episode Artwork

Skinwalker Ranch Pt. 2 ft. Ryan McCauley, Christopher Mennella, and Austin Murphy

Welcome back! This week, Anthony reads the final 3 of 6 Skinwalker Ranch stories to truly challenge the guests to choose the lie out of more stories than ever before. And to hear part 1, check out las week's episode here!: https://bit.ly/TMOLEp28 Story 4: Tom, the owner of the ranch, check on their cattle and find that a calf was completely mutilated, but no blood anywhere. A few nights later, their dogs are barking at nothing, so Tom goes to investigate and sees two strange glowing orbs inside the tree and a strange creature. He shoots the creature and goes to capture the creature, but there's only an imprint in the snow. Story 5: Tom hears a bell from the forest and goes to investigate along with someone from a research team. They don't see anything, but continue hearing the mysterious sound so eventually they head back home. The next day, he goes out to the forest and sees a 10-foot wide clearing of trees. Story 6: Two research scientists see a yellow light in the distance and see that it is growing. They realize it's a tunnel and a giant creature crawls out of the tunnel into our world, and the creature is able to evade their high-tech cameras and equipment. When the scientists to go to the area where the light was, there is no evidence of the being except for a strange musty smell in the air. Plus, in honor of trigger-happy Tom Gorman, the guys play a game called "What has Tom Gorman NOT shot?" Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Get 10% off your first month by visiting BetterHelp.com/culter35 Take advantage of SimpliSafe’s early Black Friday deals and get 50% off your new home security system by visiting SIMPLISAFE.com/culter  Follow Culter35 on YouTube Follow Culter35 on IG  Don’t forget to subscribe to the podcast for free wherever you're listening or by using this link: http://bit.ly/TrueMythsOneLiePodcast Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
11/16/202136 minutes, 53 seconds
Episode Artwork

Skinwalker Ranch Pt. 1 ft. Ryan McCauley, Austin Murphy, and Christopher Mennella

In the first of 2 parts, Anthony and guests hear 6 stories surrounding the infamous Skinwalker Ranch, a large plot of land in Utah where tons of paranormal events have occurred, even piquing the interest of the U.S. government. Story 1: A man is tending to his cattle when he spots a wolf, but upon closer inspection, they realize it's about 3 times the size of a normal wolf. The wolf attacks one of his cattle, prompting the man to shoot the wolf multiple times, barely fazing it. It finally runs away and the family gives chase, but the tracks magically disappear. Story 2: A city boy visits his family's farm to toughen him up. They bring him out on a nighttime walk when they encounter a mysterious light and begin chasing it, thinking it's a car. But the lights move more like a spaceship. Story 3: A couple are sitting outside and notice their cattle is freaking out. They then spot a strange blue orb approaching them and hovers in front of them, filling them with an immense amount of dread. The man unleashes his dogs towards the orb and it leads the dogs into the woods, but the dogs never return. Stick around next week to hear the final 3 stories! Plus, the guys play "Guess the Acronym," paranormal edition. Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Follow Culter35 on YouTube Follow Culter35 on IG   Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
11/9/202139 minutes, 35 seconds
Episode Artwork

Tom's Delivery Driver Horror Stories ft. Tom Heinlein, Ryan McCauley, and Larry Mennella

This week, guest host Tom Heinlein presents 3 insane stories from his days as a delivery driver, two of which really happened to him and one is completely made up. Listen as the guests (including host Culter35) try to separate fact from fiction. Story 1: Tom spots robbers snatch a register from a Subway sandwich shop and ride off in a bike. Tom is approached by an investigator to hear what happened. Later it's revealed that the robbers were caught by following the loose change spilling from the register. Story 2: Bernie, a weird regular of Tom's, answers the door with tattered and blood-stained clothes. He urges Tom to see what he's got in his basement. Tom politely declines and leaves. He's since delivered to Bernie several times after, but the basement mystery still remains. Story 3: A bed-ridden man orders food, so Tom delivers the food into his room. He makes a few requests, leading up to him asking Tom to clean out his bedpan. So does Tom do it? Yes, of course he does. Plus, the guys play a game of fast food-themed "Would You Rather?" to crown the ultimate fast food chain once and for all! Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Get 10% off your first month by visiting at BetterHelp.com/culter35 Follow Culter35 on YouTube Follow Culter35 on IG   Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
11/2/202138 minutes, 46 seconds
Episode Artwork

Halloween Urban Legends ft. Andrew Heinlein, Ryan McCauley, and Christopher Mennella

Since we're in spooky season, it's only appropriate that this week, Anthony brings you 3 scary legends surrounding October 31st, better known as Halloween. One legend was made up (or just started today?) by Culter 35, can you put aside your fears to figure out which one it is? Story 1: A husband and wife are vacationing when they spot a Halloween party. The woman wants to go, the man does not and an argument ensues. When they return to the hotel room, the man snaps and brutally murders his wife, all the while maniacally laughing. The police arrive and the man slits his own throat, still laughing until his death. Legend has it, if you stay in this same room, you will still hear his laughter. Story 2: A group of convicts are being transferred to a local asylum. The bus crashes and the convicts escape. They're able to catch all but two, but find a trail of half-eaten bunnies leading to a nearby bridge and a creepy note. The 2nd escaped convict has yet to be found. Legend has it that if you find yourself on this bridge, you will be skinned and murdered by The Bunny Man. Story 3: A young boy is playing near some power lines, when he's accidentally electrified and mutilated, yet survives. He begins secluding himself and eventually lives out his life in the tunnels. Legend has it that if you drive through one of these tunnels, you might get a glimpse of the Green Man, and it might be your last day on earth. Plus, the guests play "Tricked or Treat" where Anthony describes various murder scenes and everyone must guest which killer or creature is the culprit, and the guests play for candy and Krabby Patties. Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Visit SIMPLISAFE.com/culter to get 20% off your entire new system and your first month of monitoring service FREE, when you enroll in Interactive Monitoring! Follow Culter35 on YouTube Follow Culter35 on IG   Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
10/26/202139 minutes, 25 seconds
Episode Artwork

C13Features Presents: Treat, Starring Kiernan Shipka

True Myths One Lie presents an exclusive preview of a brand new podcast movie from C13Features called "Treat" starring Kiernan Shipka. Welcome to Treat, a brand new thrilling and frightening podcast movie listening experience from C13Features. In Treat, Kiernan Shipka stars as Allie West, an unpopular teenager who is dealing with issues beyond her years while struggling to fit in with her seemingly perfect small town. But, on one Halloween night, everything changes, and she discovers that her town’s idyllic image comes at a terrifying price. As she learns about the mysterious Piper’s powerful hold on the town, she, along with her younger brother, realize they are the only ones who can save their community before it rots at the hands of The Piper. Can Allie West help rescue her family, and their town, and even herself, from its evil past and own demise? Get ready to pop some popcorn, and get lost in your imagination in this chilling new podcast movie experience. Treat, from C13Features, available now. Go find and listen to Treat wherever you get your podcasts! Follow Culter35 on YouTube Follow Culter35 on IG   Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
10/26/20213 minutes, 43 seconds
Episode Artwork

Mothman ft. Ryan McCauley, Andrew Heinlein, and Christopher Mennella

It's part moth, it's part man, Mothman. This week, Anthony and crew hear 3 stories about the Southern urban legend who differs from other cryptids in that people believe it is a benevolent creature. Can you figure out which one is the lie before the end of the episode? Story 1: A woman is suddenly drawn to her window, where she encounters the Mothman creature. Even though she's terrified, she feels a strange comfort and she begins sensing something from him. A few weeks later, there is a terrible bridge collapse, where various others had previously reported seeing the being. Story 2: A young boy (named Mister) comes out of a meditation to see the giant Mothman before him. They begin communicating telepathically where the boy feels a variety of emotions, ending in complete tranquility, something that has lasted his entire life. Story 3: A man living in a trailer is awakened by a noise. When he investigates, he finds the Mothman hovering around his baby sister. The man screams, causing the creature to panic, grab the man and fly out of the trailer. The next day, his parents find him unconscious on the ground, living with the trauma of the experience to this day. Plus, the guys play another round of "Guess Who" but instead of a person, they have to guess the creature, Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Get 15% off their Raycon order at BUYRAYCON.com/true  Follow Culter35 on YouTube Follow Culter35 on IG   Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
10/19/202133 minutes, 29 seconds
Episode Artwork

Dark Watchers ft. Ryan McCauley, Austin Murphy, and Christopher Mennella

There's a Californian folklore regarding figures named "dark watchers," shadowy entities that seemingly follow hikers and travelers, and people have sworn to have seen them in other parts of the country. This week, Culter35 and guests debate 3 stories regarding these mystic figures, but one story is totally fake. Story 1: A man gets a radio call from a coworker who frighteningly tells him he sees something strange. The man goes to investigate and sees a 7-foot-tall shadow creature approaching him. The figure eventually catches up to him and they have a face-off. Story 2: A family is traveling to their campsite. The girl in the family keeps seeing figures in the trees, but the parents chalk it up to an active imagination. Eventually, the car slams to a stop when there is a dark watcher in the middle of the road. Story 3: 2 friends are driving around some haunted barns when their car breaks down. They decide to just stay in the car overnight until sunrise. Eventually, they're surrounded by large shadowy creatures that never move an inch. Plus, the guys play a version of "Mad Libs" where some words of a creepy story are filled in by the guests with silly words. Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Follow Culter35 on YouTube Follow Culter35 on IG   Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
10/12/202141 minutes, 42 seconds
Episode Artwork

Even More Warren Cases ft. Austin Murphy, Zach Sicardi, and Christopher Mennella

In the first sequel of T.M.O.L., this week, Anthony and guests are discussing 3 stories involving Ed and Lorraine Warren, a married couple who were also paranormal investigators and Story 1: A boy practices spells using a mirror, using his powers to get back at people he didn't like. But in doing so, he unleashes evil spirits into his own home, which causes his family to enlist the Warrens. The Warrens take away the mirror, where it still sits in their museum to this day. Story 2: A woman wins $100,000 on a game show which she uses to buy a home. Her husband gets into an accident and begins acting strangely. One night, the woman sees a dark figure in his wheelchair and the husband confirms he's been seeing it as well. The Warrens are called and take away the wheelchair, becoming another relic in their museum. Story 3: A teenage girl makes contact with a spirit, who begins saying the things she wants to hear. She is able to manifest the spirit in her home, but it begins causing havoc around the house. The Warrens come and discover that it's actually a demonic spirit and begins physically attacking people in the home. An exorcist is able to cleanse the home and bring back peace to the home. Plus, the guests listen to 4 mythical creatures, 3 of which people swear they've run into and one of which that was totally made up. Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Get 15% off their Raycon order at BUYRAYCON.com/true Follow Culter35 on YouTube Follow Culter35 on IG   Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
10/5/202136 minutes, 9 seconds
Episode Artwork

Glitches in the Matrix ft. Andrew Heinlein, Ryan McCauley, and Christopher Mennella

With the new Matrix movie coming out, it makes sense that this week Anthony is discussing times where people have experience glitches in the fabric of reality where people either travelled through time, entered a different dimension or a combination of the two. Story 1: A couple smokes a cigarette with their friend when a random man comes up to them asking for a smoke. They refuse so the man attacks them and starts stabbing them, until they both experience a white flash. They find themselves in a theatre watching a movie. They leave and find that their brand new pack is open and see the same crazy guy walking past. Story 2: A man shows up to work at a juvenile detention center, confusing his supervisor because he just received a call that he wasn't coming in. The man finds a message from himself calling out sick. When he calls home, he answers the phone and they confusingly talk to themselves. When the man rushes home, he finds his wife calmly watching TV. On top of that, a storm took the power out making it impossible for him to have called home in the first place. Story 3: Some college kids drive to a party. When they arrive, they don't see any cars or signs of a party, despite being late. When they finally enter the home, the house is suddenly full of people and music. They stay over, but the next day their car is nowhere to be found. Plus, the guests play "Glitch in the Matrix or Glitch in a Video Game?" where Culter35 lists some glitches, some of which was just a coding error, and some that happened in real life. Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Go to magicspoon.com/TRUE to save $5 today! Follow Culter35 on YouTube Follow Culter35 on IG Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
9/28/202136 minutes, 33 seconds
Episode Artwork

SCP Stories ft. Ryan McCauley, Seth Colon, and Christopher Mennella

See if you can follow us on this one. If you're unfamiliar with SCPs (Secure, Contain, Protect), they're essentially a vast self-contained universe where strange creatures and entities are added to its canon by users. In essence, everything is fake, but in this episode, the guests try to guess which is the "fakest", in other words, the one that Anthony made up. SCP 1: "Painting" - A painting allows authorized people to step into it and enter a drawn dimension. This story details the experiences of 3 research subjects who dared to step in and one who never stepped out. SCP 2: "Duct Tape" - A (non-offensive) roll of duct tape is able to remove facial features of a person when it's placed on them. SCP 3: "Tower" - A large building is destroyed, then being rebuilt again. Some people explore the building and find a trap door, which leads to a seemingly endless recreation of the tower and trap door. Various people have re-explored these trap doors and encounter eerie events, assuming they made it out at all. Plus, the guys play "Fill in the blank" where Anthony reads a real post about Big Foot by an online user, but with some key words taken out and it's up to the guests to figure out the missing words. Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Go to magicspoon.com/TRUE to save $5 today! Follow Culter35 on YouTube Follow Culter35 on IG   Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
9/21/202136 minutes, 49 seconds
Episode Artwork

The Chupacabra ft. Andrew Heinlein, Christopher Mennella, and Seth Colon

The literal translation is "goat sucker." Chupacabra is a legendary creature that sucks the blood out of various livestock, terrorizing farmers in the Western hemisphere for decades. Culter35 and crew discuss 3 stories involving encounters with this infamous urban legend. Can you figure out which one Anthony made up? Story 1: Three brothers and their parents visit their extended family in Mexico. Once there, the boys run into several mutilated deer and scratch marks on various trees. The eldest brother wants to see the creature, so he sets out into the woods and, much to his dismay, he gets his wish. Story 2: Two women are hiking in the Andes Mountains. While camping, they hear a strange noise in the distance, but decide to let it go. The next day, they experience a heat wave and start running through their water quickly, causing an argument. Their yelling stirs a strange creature out of hiding and starts chasing them. Story 3: A man returns to visit the farm where his grandfather lives. In the middle of the night, the grandson hears a cow fighting for its life. When he investigates, he runs into the Chupacabra attacking livestock. The man and grandfather are able to stun and burn it to death, but this is old news for the grandfather. Plus, the guys play "Guess Who" where they try to figure out which creature Anthony is thinking of with only 5 questions (or maybe more) at their disposal. Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Sign up with MyBookie and use promo code MYTHS to instantly receive double your first deposit! Visit https://bit.ly/MB-MYTHS to get started today! Follow Culter35 on YouTube Follow Culter35 on IG   Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
9/14/202136 minutes, 23 seconds
Episode Artwork

Conspiracy Theories ft. Ryan McCauley & Christopher Mennella

We're living in a divided world where conspiracy theories are rampant, so why not add a few more? This week, Anthony and guests put on their tin foil hats and discuss 3 off-the-wall conspiracy theories, one of which that Anthony made up... or did he? Yes, he did. Theory 1: The technology brand Apple funds apple orchards so that when people go apple picking, they're continually thinking about apples and, subsequently, Apple products. Theory 2: Israel and Egypt have been at war for years. In a clever attempt at retaliation, Israel has GPS-monitored sharks that they send to popular beaches in Egypt to affect their tourism revenue. Theory 3: The cheese Illuminati, a secret government group that is trying to cram more cheese into American mouths due to an extreme surplus of cheese. Plus, they play "Name that price", where Culter35 lists off some truly bizarre items that are currently on sale online and the guests must guess what the asking price is. Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Sign up with MyBookie and use promo code MYTHS to instantly receive double your first deposit! Visit https://bit.ly/MB-MYTHS to get started today! Right now, get 15% off your Raycon order at BUYRAYCON.com/true Follow Culter35 on YouTube Follow Culter35 on IG Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
9/7/202138 minutes, 6 seconds
Episode Artwork

Haunted Mirrors ft. Zach Sicardi, Austin Murphy, and Christopher Mennella

Have you ever looked in the mirror and not like what you saw? Well, these stories are about that, but not in the typical sense. This week, Culter35 and crew discuss 3 stories of haunted mirrors, mirrors with unusual powers that cause people to see visions, get sucked into paranormal worlds, and can even kill. Story 1: A boy is cleaning his home when he gets to the basement. Little did he know that there's a haunted mirror down there. He slowly goes into a trance, seeing horrible figures and visions. Story 2: 2 men explore an abandoned funeral home. One of the men discovers this mirror and takes it home. His friend comes over and is drawn to the mirror and gets stuck in a trance, seeing a future version of himself, causing him to run out of his home. The man is still skeptical, until a hand from the mirror makes him think otherwise. Story 3: A family hires a nanny to care for their home. The nanny is continually drawn to an antique mirror, until she's completely drawn in and has to be taken to a witch doctor. The family transports the mirror, but it accidentally shatters which has very dire consequences. Plus, Anthony lists several creepy Craigslist ads, some of which he made up, and it's up to the guests to figure out what horrifying things actually exist on the internet. Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Sign up with MyBookie and use promo code MYTHS to get your first-ever deposit matched dollar-for-dollar! Visit https://bit.ly/MB-MYTHS to get started today! Follow Culter35 on YouTube Follow Culter35 on IG   Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
8/31/202135 minutes, 13 seconds
Episode Artwork

Imaginary Friends ft. Tom Heinlein, Katie Heinlein, and Larry Mennella

This week, Culter35 brings you 3 stories of kids interacting with their imaginary friends, often with some creepy results. One of the stories is made up, will you able to figure out which? Story 1: A boy visits his cousin who is preoccupied with his imaginary friend Jimmy. He gets mad and tells his cousin his friend Jimmy isn't real. That night, the boy's cousin hides under the bed and scares the other boy because his imaginary friend needed him to re-earn his trust. Story 2: A 10-year-old boy makes an imaginary friend to make up for not being the most popular. One night, the parents find that the boy has stabbed all of his stuffed animals with a fork because his friend told him to. Another night, the boy is instructed to go into his baby brother's room and set things on fire. Story 3: A boy watches his twin sisters while their mom works late. One night, he checks on them and finds that one of the twins has a clock written on her homework set to 3. Later at 3, the power shuts off and the boy finds that everything has been unplugged. Plus, the guests invent a new mythical creature using a random word generator. Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Follow Culter35 on YouTube Follow Culter35 on IG  Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
8/24/202137 minutes, 7 seconds
Episode Artwork

Obscure Horror Films (and a new host!) ft. Seth Colon, Ryan McCauley, and Christopher Mennella

In a classic horror movie twist, Anthony passes hosting duties to Seth, and Anthony tries his hand at figuring out the fake story. This week, Seth gives the summary to 3 seriously off-the-wall mystery/horror films from yesteryear, one of which he completely made up. And for the record, this episode is NOT sponsored by Shudder. Film 1: Veronica is the only vegetarian in a meat-crazy town. When all the meat runs out, all eyes look to Veronica as the main suspect. The solution? Sacrificing Veronica. Film 2: A New York detective realizes there is a serial killer in his midst. The strange part is the killer's voice sounds like beloved cartoon character Donald Duck. Film 3: A high school cheerleader, Tammy, starts dating a football player. Her jealous boyfriend hunts him down and feed him to lions. A mad scientist recovers his brain and places it into a robotic T-Rex. Plus, the guys guess which unusually famous actor is in 3 bonus actually real scary motion pictures. Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Follow Culter35 on YouTube. Follow Culter35 on IG. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
8/17/202132 minutes, 51 seconds
Episode Artwork

Haunted Staircases in the Woods ft. Ryan McCauley and Seth Colon

Did you read the title?! This week, Anthony and friends discuss 3 distinct stories regarding people finding a mysterious set of stairs in the woods that were probably best left unexplored. Story 1: A man finds an ever-growing set of stairs in the middle of the woods, but attempts to ignore them, but the trail around him has disappeared. He then spots a strange man who ignores him. He then finds a trove of random shoes scattered around. When he finally finds his way out, he reports his findings to a park ranger. The park ranger informs him that another person previously encountered the stairs, but the only thing he left behind were a set of shoes. Story 2: A woman goes on a class trip into some woods. She takes a rest and soon realizes she's completely alone. When she tries to find her group, she encounters a set of stairs. When she steps onto them, she's engulfed by complete silence and is met with a demon-like woman. She runs away, but gets pushed by the being and is left with scars. Story 3: A man and his grandfather go hunting the woods. Somehow the man gets separated from his grandpa and spots a giant set of stairs. He's able to call him, but the call gets lost. He begins going up the stairs and hears his grandfather scream when he reaches the top. When he gets down, he sees his grandfather covered in blood on his feet. Plus, the guys play a multiple-choice game where they guess which one of the bizarre creatures listed was made up by Culter35. Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Follow Culter35 on YouTube. Follow Culter35 on IG. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
8/10/202138 minutes, 57 seconds
Episode Artwork

The Warren Cases ft. Andrew Heinlein, Hope Heinlein, and Jessica Signorello-Heinlein

This week, the Heinleins and Anthony talk through 3 stories about Ed and Lorraine Warrens, infamous paranormal investigators who were the inspirations behind the Conjuring films and heavily involved. Anthony reads 3 cases of paranormal activity that the Warrens investigated, one of which was made up. Case 1: A woman tells the Warrens that her children have been being attacked by malevolent forces after one of her children dabbled in witchcraft. Case 2: A couple tells the Warrens they bought their son a toy truck that mysteriously moves around at night. They also notice that their son has strange markings all over his body. Case 3: A limousine arrives to take Ed and Lorraine to a military academy. When they arrive, a government official tells them about strange occurrences at his home. Plus, Anthony takes an online and makes it into a game of Mad Libs and there's a MAJOR twist when the reveal arrives. Create your own soundtrack, with Raycon. Right now, get 15% off at BUYRAYCON.com/true Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Follow Culter35 on YouTube Follow Culter35 on IG   Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
8/3/202136 minutes, 42 seconds
Episode Artwork

Sleep Paralysis Demons ft. Andrew Heinlein and Ryan McCauley

If you've never experienced sleep paralysis, consider yourself lucky! This week, Anthony and crew discuss 3 terrifying stories that may make it harder for you to sleep tonight. The only catch is that one of the stories is totally made up. Can you guess which one is the lie? Story 1: A man is awoken to a scraping noise. He spots a creature scratching at the walls. The creature slowly approaches him, but the man is frozen. The creature grabs the man by his arm and throws him, causing him to finally wake up. Story 2: A woman with a headache tries to nap. She wakes up to footsteps behind her. She feels a warm body pressing up against her. She tries to turn or wake herself up, but she is frozen. The entity whispers to her and lingers for a bit too long. Story 3: A man wakes up in the middle of night and realizes he can't move. He spots a large shadowy figure approaching him from the door. The figure assures him as he slowly reaches the man, placing his hand on the man and giving him chills. Plus, we're bringing back "What's that SCP?", where the guests try to figure out the lore behind the title "A Gift From Dad." Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Follow Culter35 on YouTube. Follow Culter35 on IG. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
7/27/202138 minutes, 15 seconds
Episode Artwork

The Dogman Legend ft. Ryan McCulley, Austin Murphy, Christopher Mennella

Half dog, half man, the Dogman, it's really that simple. This week, Culter35 and crew discuss the long-standing myth of the cryptid known as the dogman. You'll hear 3 stories, one of which was totally made up. Can you guess which one? Story 1: A family moves into a new house and the father installs cameras around the property. When the man and his son go to check on the cameras, they find one smashed on the ground. They collect the memory cards of all the cameras to investigate, but while out in the woods, they spot the dogman creature. The creature grabs the son by the neck, so the family attacks the dogman causing him to drop the child. Story 2: A man is driving and encounters 2 menacing creatures. He hits one of the dogmen and speeds off, crashing his car. He's able to narrowly escape and treat his injuries at the hospital, where he recounts the full story. Story 3: A family hears strange noises in the middle of the night. When the grandfather investigates, he sees several dogmen surrounding the home. They start attacking, so they begin shooting at the creatures and is able to make them retreat. The family protects the house until the sun comes up. Plus, the guys play "Go Figure," where Anthony gives the first half of a super generic ghost story and everyone fills in the rest. Get 10% Off by visiting BetterHelp.com/culter35! Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Follow Culter35 on YouTube Follow Culter35 on IG  Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
7/20/202136 minutes, 23 seconds
Episode Artwork

Precognition ft. Ryan McCauley, Hunter Ferreira

Have you ever had Deja vu? Well, this is kind of like that, but times ten. Anthony brings you and his guests 3 stories of people predicting the future in their dreams and having it come true. Story 1: A woman gets into a car accident. Days later, she keeps getting urges to speak to a particular friend whenever she's mentioned. Some time passes, and she gets news that this friend died in a car accident. Story 2: A woman continually dreams about this mystery man, and senses that this could be her future husband. When she moves to a completely different state, she runs into a man who she identifies from her dream. After dating for a while, she confesses her dreams when he reveals that he too had dreamt of her too. Story 3: A woman dreams that she is pregnant, though there are complications. When she eventually gets tested, she discovers that she is indeed pregnant and her daughter has a rare condition. Get 10% off your first month by visiting BetterHelp.com/culter35! Plus, Ryan calls his sister who often has precognitions to guess which story is fake without having heard any of them, and the guys play another round of "Plotline or Conspiracy Theory?" Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Follow Culter35 on YouTube Follow Culter35 on IG   Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
7/13/202135 minutes, 54 seconds
Episode Artwork

Black-Eyed Children ft. Tom Heinlein, Larry Mennella

No, these aren't kids who got into a fight, these are mysterious children who ask for help with vacant pitch-black voids where there eyes should be. If you help them out, you are forever cursed with bad luck. Story 1: A man goes for a swim in a nearby lake. He hears a child asking for help and spots a little girl. When he gets to her, she asks to be helped across the lake, but he sees her eyes are pitch-black. He refuses, then she asks to go home with him. He refuses and swims away, but the child follows after him in the lake. Story 2: A couple walk back to their car from a midnight showing. A kid tugs on the man's shirt and asks for spare change. When the man refuses, he asks again repeatedly. The couple gets in the car and locks the door and sees the child has black eyes. The man speeds off and sees the child chasing after the car and screaming. Story 3: A man walks back home from his night shift. On his walk, he sees 2 children holding hands and crossing the street over and over. They finally reach the man and ask to use his phone at home. When he gets a creepy feeling, he decides to walk away, and the children set off to find another victim. Plus, the guys play "Guess Who?" a game based off the popular board game, but a mythical creature edition. And Anthony talks about his run-in with the Slenderman lore. Get 20% off + free shipping with the code TRUEMYTHS at manscaped.com! Get 10% off your first month by visiting BetterHelp.com/culter35! Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Follow Culter35 on YouTube Follow Culter35 on IG Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
7/6/202137 minutes, 21 seconds
Episode Artwork

Bigfoot is Now My Godfather ft. Ryan Feeney, Austin Murphy & Christopher Mennella

Bigfoot, Yeti, Sasquatch, whatever you call it, there's been lore about the elusive beast for decades. This week, Culter35 and crew dissect 3 stories of Bigfoot encounters, one of which is totally made up. Story 1: A man wants to bring his girlfriend along with him and his friends to his birthday camping trip. He finally convinces her to go, even though she's never been camping before. After a fun night, everyone is asleep except for the girlfriend. She starts hearing some strange sounds from outside the tent. She wakes everyone else up and they suddenly hear a loud bang followed by a strange smell. All of a sudden, the tent is attacked and the creature runs off. Story 2: Two large families are hanging out at a large property. A couple of the kids break off and run around with the family dog. All of a sudden, they start to smell a foul odor, so bad it causes one of them to vomit. They go to investigate and find a large creature running off and climbing an impossibly steep hill. They freak out and tell their parents, but no one believes them. Story 3: A man visits a ranch where the owner claims that a lot of strange things goes on there. While out hunting, he follows a trail of broken trees, huge hand and footprints, but it goes cold. At night, they go searching again along the same trial, but this time, they hear a loud noise surrounding them. They run to their car and turn on the headlights, there are 2 Bigfoot approaching them. Plus, the guys play a Bigfoot-themed game of "Mad Libs." Get 10% Off by visiting BetterHelp.com/culter35! Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Follow Culter35 on YouTube Follow Culter35 on IG  Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
6/29/202136 minutes, 23 seconds
Episode Artwork

Creepy Clowns ft. Jessica Signorello, Andrew Heinlein, Christopher Mannella

Are you a fan of the circus or does your fear of clowns keep you away? This week, Anthony brings 3 stories involving clowns that probably won't make you laugh. Story 1: A freshman in college is looking to make friends, so she takes a dance class. After leaving class one night, she runs into a large man wearing a killer clown mask. She runs away into a random building and waits for campus police. When they arrive, they find no trace of man. Story 2: A man is sick at home when he hears some strange noise. When he goes to the kitchen, he finds a clown cooking food and she begins screaming at him. When the police arrive, Story 3: A woman starts a new job, where she meets some bike enthusiasts. She looks online to find an affordable bike and finds one nearby. When she goes to pick up the bike, a clown runs up to her window, and she speeds out of there. Plus, everyone plays a few rousing rounds of "Would You Rather?" Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Follow Culter35 on YouTube Follow Culter35 on IG  Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
6/22/202137 minutes, 8 seconds
Episode Artwork

Disney's Creepiest Encounters ft. Ryan McCauley & Seth Colon

Is it the Happiest or the Creepiest Place on Earth? This week, Anthony brings you 3 stories of spooky encounters that have happened at Disney Theme Parks, though the guys had trouble deciding which park specifically, one of which that Anthony dreamed up. And if Ryan and Seth get this right, they will get a free trip to Disney! Disneyland or Disneyworld? We're still not sure. Story 1: A new employee is the last in his shift when he runs into a lost little girl. After looking around for her parents, the girl is nowhere to be found. And this is just one of many creepy encounters for this poor "Cast Member." Story 2: A custodian is cleaning up the bathrooms late at night when he hears a mysterious noise. When he goes to investigate, he sees that some items have been shifted around. After some shock, he hears a voice whisper to him, causing to end his shift early. Story 3: A couple approaches Splash Mountain near the park closing and they get the ride all to themselves. Midway through, the ride gets stuck. When the couple finally get to the end of the ride, they seem disturbed. When they look at the ride photo, there is a unknown third passenger sitting next to them. Plus, the guys play "True or False: Disney Edition," where Culter35 lists some unsettling rumors regarding Disney like real bones being used in the Pirates ride, the Main Street ghost, and more! Get 10% Off by visiting BetterHelp.com/culter35! Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Follow Culter35 on YouTube Follow Culter35 on IG Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
6/15/202136 minutes, 54 seconds
Episode Artwork

Humanoid Creatures ft. Matt Casa & Christopher Mannella

This week, Anthony brings his guests 3 stories about humanoid creatures (these are animals that behave human-like) having run-ins with very scared people. So if your pet starts walking on its hind legs, maybe sleep with one eye open. Story 1: A couple gets into a fight, so the boyfriend goes on a walk to clear his head. But instead of a peaceful walk, he has an encounter with a reptile-like creature. Frozen in fear, the only thing that sames him is a passing car. Story 2: A man is watching his nieces as they play in the backyard. After a bit, he hears a scream and runs out. His nieces claim that they were almost lured into the woods by frog people, but the scream scared them off. When he investigates, he finds the locked gate broken. Story 3: A few friends are driving up a mountain for a getaway, When they finally make it to the top, they spot a dog passing by them. The dog sits in the middle of the road and turns to the friends. But this is no ordinary dog, instead of a cute and cuddly face, the dog's face looks like an old woman's face sewn onto its own. Plus, the guys play "Invent a mythical creature," where Culter35 provides them two words "snake" and "earwax" and the guests must invent a new creepy humanoid of their own. Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Follow Culter35 on YouTube Follow Culter35 on IG  Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
6/8/202136 minutes, 10 seconds
Episode Artwork

Shadow People Hate Single People ft. Austin Murphy and Christopher Mennella

Not to be confused with ghosts, a shadow person might be operating in a realm close to ours and are entirely different beings than just dead people. This week, Culter35 challenges you (and his 2 guests) to sort true encounters from one he just totally made up. Story 1: Two women on vacation are getting ready for bed when a motion sensor light continually turns on. When they check out the light, they find nothing. But the continued creepy experiences causes them to rush out of the hotel, check out and end their vacation early. Story 2: A couple walks a trail after a nice dinner. Both the man and the woman see a shadow figure, but don't speak about until near the end of their date, realizing what they saw was all too real. Story 3: Three friends are hanging out when one friend realizes she left her phone in the park. When her and another friend go to retrieve it, they're confronted by a large shadow figure. They panic and try to escape, but keep running into the wrong buildings. When they finally make it back, one of the girls says she's been followed by this being all her life. Plus, Anthony and crew play "You Saw WHAT?!" The guys try to discern local urban myths from one that Anthony pulled from his nightmares. The creatures include the Loveland frog, giant frogs that walk on their hind legs, The Haggerman groundhog, mysterious creatures creating large holes in the ground, The New Jersey Mantis, a human-sized praying mantis near bodies of water, and the Ohio grass man, a foul-smelling beast that would put Bigfoot to shame. Get 20% Off and Free Shipping with the code TRUEMYTHS at Manscaped.com! Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Follow Culter35 on YouTube Follow Culter35 on IG   Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
6/1/202136 minutes, 51 seconds
Episode Artwork

Cryptids & Even More Pizza! ft. Andrew Heinlein and Christopher Mennella

This week's episode is all about creatures that you won't find at the zoo, cryptids, mythical beings that are sometimes animal-like, sometimes human-like, always scary. Andrew and Christopher listen as Culter35 lists off 3 cryptid encounters, 2 that the people involved swear are true, and one completely fabricated. Story 1: 5 friends are hanging out in their car when 2 of the friends spot something in the distance. They see 7 ft.-tall white figure. When the other friends look towards the creature, it has seemingly disappeared. After a few moments, there's a white flash behind them. It's the creature and it's coming towards them. Story 2: A child is watching his siblings while his aunt is out. He hears a knock at door and a voice claiming to be his aunt. When he looks through the peephole, he sees what appears to be a skinwalker, hairy and disfigured. The boy runs upstairs, locks himself away and calls his aunt for help. Story 3: A park ranger is performing a search and rescue for a missing woman. After a while, he's able to find the woman crying behind some bushes, only she's not missing, she's hiding. The ranger guides her back to her concerned friends, but hears footsteps following them. When he is finally able to get his flashlight out, he sees a flash of a haunting white face that's gone just as fast as it appeared. Plus, the guys play "Fill in the Blank," where Anthony reals a real reddit post involving "Dog Man" but leaves out a few key words. Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Follow Culter35 on YouTube Follow Culter35 on IG Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
5/25/202135 minutes, 32 seconds
Episode Artwork

Ghost Stories & The Podcast Falls Apart ft. Seth Colon, Ryan McCauley, and Christopher Mennella

This week, we hear 3 spooky stories, two of which the victims swear are true and one of which was made up by Culter35 for the show. Guests Seth Colon, Ryan McCauley, and Christopher Mennella try to sort the truth from the lie, all while Anthony loses control of the entire show. Story 1: A child is woken up to loud footsteps above him, but after some investigation, he can't quite spot the source. Later that night, he awakes to some pressure on his chest, but doesn't dare open his eyes until it passes. He decides to pray it away, and this seems to do the trick. But that's proven to be in vein when he wakes up the next night to a shadowy hand grabbing him and an unknown woman at his bed, Story 2: The child of a family is visiting their summer home for some fun and relaxation. But one night, the child starts to get a strange feeling. When he wakes up, he's completely deaf, though it ultimately passes. When he seeks comfort, he finds his brother in a room, only something isn't quite right. His brother's creepy smile makes the boy uneasy, and he runs to another room, only to find his real brother sitting there. Story 3: A man is house sitting for his boss and has a few friends over for a night of games. It's not long until they start experiencing some strange & paranormal activity, finally culminating in the house being infested with fleas. The friends hightail it out of the house, leaving the employee to clean up the house, but the fleas are all gone. While heading for his final exit, a mysterious force holds him back. When he finally gets the guts to turn around, he is face to face with a terrifying figure. Plus, the guys play a game called "What's that SCP?" where Anthony's guests try to come up with the tale of "The Indoor Salesman," a real SCP story. Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Follow Culter35 on YouTube Follow Culter35 on IG Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
5/18/202135 minutes, 48 seconds
Episode Artwork

Urban Legends That (Mostly) Turned Out to Be True ft. Ryan McCauley, Ryan Feeney and Christopher Mennella

This week on the podcast, Culter35 and guests Ryan McCauley, Ryan Feeney and Christopher Mennella discuss 3 urban legends that have circulated around schoolyards and water coolers for a while now, and 2 of which have now been found to be 100% true. Check out the story details below: Story #1: Mrs. Knight was known around town for carrying an axe with her, but nothing more than a strange, if not mildly dangerous nuisance. That was until police discovered her unusual dinner table setting. When investigators walked into Mrs. Knight's home, they found her passed out nearby an empty table with the children's names labeled on 3 separate plates, but no husband. But that's not because Mr. Knight was late for dinner, it's because he WAS dinner. Mrs. Knight had attempted to feed the children their own father! Story #2: Back when people could congregate and socialize in malls, shoppers were unaware that when they returned to their cars, they were in for more slashing than just the prices. A mysterious man and/or potentially several people were hiding under parked cars and cutting people's ankles, before taking off back to their gang leader, because apparently the price of admission to the group was a piece of flesh. Story #3: A young boy woke up from a deep sleep to a strange figure in his room, holding nothing but a candle. He whispered "Shh, I'm your dad," before retreating into the night, leaving nothing but traces of candle wax. When the boy reported this the next day, he found out he was far from the only one to see the man in his room, a man who was later dubbed "The Candlelight Prowler." Plus, the guys play "Go Figure," the game where Anthony tells us a run-of-the-mill (but supposedly true) ghost story with every cliche in the book, and everyone tries to guess how it ends. So do you think you can sort the verified from the unverified? Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Follow Culter35 on YouTube Follow Culter35 on IG Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
5/11/202133 minutes, 1 second
Episode Artwork

Alien Abductions and a Pizza Party ft. Andrew Heinlein, Ryan McCauley, and Christopher Mennella

In the very first episode, Andrew Heinlein, Ryan McCauley, and Christopher Mennella join the show to play the first game of “True Myths, One Lie,” the podcast game show where Culter35 presents 3 distinct stories, but one is completely made up. What’s at stake? Pride, honor and an amazing pizza party. Plus, the guys play “Plotline or conspiracy theory?” involving a Sasquatch being hidden from authorities.    Story 1: A mysterious red light follows two friends that haunts one of the men for years. Through therapy, he recalls being abducted by aliens and being experimented on. Story 2: While on a business trip, a man discovers a seemingly abandoned UFO in a field. He crawls around the ships and even finds fallen alien beings. Several days later, the man starts experiencing strange physical ailments that leaves doctors baffled. Story 3: A man is being followed by another strange light. He pulls over thinking it’s the police, but eventually the lights subside. Soon after, his car is completely dead and the next few hours are a blur. When he finally looks at his phone, he’s lost over 4 hours of time.   Will you be able to figure out the lie? Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to truemythsonelie@gmail.com! Follow Culter35 on YouTube Follow Culter35 on IG Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
5/4/202129 minutes, 32 seconds
Episode Artwork

Introducing: True Myths, One Lie!

True Myths, One Lie is a game show in the form of a podcast. Each week we’ll be diving into three of the craziest stories about ghosts, urban legends, crimes and much more. Two of these stories are claimed to be true, the other we’ve made up. Do you have what it takes to figure out which one is the lie? Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
3/29/202138 seconds